Skip to content
ScreenCastMeadow

Gear ยท twelve listings in four groups

Streaming Players & Displays

apps for a screen that may already have them

This is the category that creates the doubling. Every device here is sold to put an app platform on a screen, and most of the televisions in this catalog already state one.

Three of the listings in this category are not television players at all. They are smart displays, and only one of the three states a television platform inside it. They are kept here because that is where a catalog puts them, and they are grouped apart and labeled so nobody buys one expecting a stick.

About the smart displays on this pageThree listings in this category are smart displays rather than players for a television. Two of them state no television platform at all. They are grouped separately below and are never described here as a way of putting apps onto a television.

Fire TV sticks

Five listings

Every listing in this group states a Fire TV platform. Two of them are named Fire TV Stick HD and carry different ASINs, so they are two listings, not one listing shown twice.

Fire TV sticks: five listings compared on six points that differ

Identical on all five, so not shown as a columnPlatform stated: Fire TV.

Fire TV sticks, compared on the points where the listings differ
ListingResolution statedWi-Fi statedRemote statedSearch statedPower statedAssistant stated
Fire TV Stick 4K Plus4KWi-Fi 6Not statedAI-powered Fire TV SearchNot statedAlexa+
Fire TV Stick 4K Select4K streamingNot statedNot statedAI-powered searchNot statedAlexa+
Fire TV Stick 4K Max4KWi-Fi 6ENot statedAI-powered Fire TV SearchNot statedNot stated
Fire TV Stick HD, newest modelHDNot statedAlexa Voice RemoteNot statedPowered by the TVAlexa+
Fire TV Stick HD, smart home controlsHD streamingNot statedAlexa Voice RemoteNot statedNot statedNot stated

Six of the recorded points differ across this group. Where a listing says nothing, the cell reads not stated, which is not the same as absent.

  • Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Plus (newest model)
    Straight to the category job

    First in this category. The core job here is apps for a screen that may already have them, and this listing states a Fire TV platform and nothing else that distracts from it.

    Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Plus (newest model)

    • The apps

    The listing states AI-powered Fire TV Search, Wi-Fi 6, free and live TV and Alexa+. That is a Fire TV app platform in a stick, which is the exact job four of the eight televisions in this catalog already state on their own boxes.

    What the listing states

    • The listing states a Fire TV platform, so what it does with the apps job is not in doubt
    • Wi-Fi 6 is stated, which only one other listing in this category states
    • AI-powered Fire TV Search is stated as part of the platform, not as a separate purchase
    • Free and live TV is stated, so the platform is described as usable without another subscription being named

    What it does not

    • The listing text quoted here does not name a remote in the box, unlike both Fire TV Stick HD listings
    • Nothing in the listing can tell you which platform is already in your television
    • No storage figure is stated, so there is nothing here to compare against the one listing that states one

    SuitsA screen whose own platform is either absent or no longer the one the household wants to use.

    View listing
  • Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Select (newest model)
    Named Select in the listing

    The listing carries the Select naming, which is how it is told apart from the Plus and the Max on the shelf. Nothing else in its text is unique to it, so nothing else is claimed.

    Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Select (newest model)

    • The apps

    The listing states 4K streaming, AI-powered search, free and live TV and Alexa+. It is the Select naming in the Fire TV stick line, and the text is close enough to its neighbors that no claim of being the only anything is made about it here.

    What the listing states

    • A Fire TV platform is stated, so the apps job is covered by the listing itself
    • 4K streaming is stated in plain words rather than left to the model name
    • Free and live TV is stated as part of the platform
    • Alexa+ is stated, which two of the five sticks in this group do not state

    What it does not

    • No remote is named in the listing text quoted here
    • No Wi-Fi generation is stated, unlike two of its neighbors in this group
    • Nothing in the listing addresses the platform already built into the screen it plugs into

    SuitsSomebody who wants the Fire TV platform stated at 4K without the extras the other listings in this group name.

    View listing
  • Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max (newest model)
    Only Wi-Fi 6E stated here

    Wi-Fi 6E support appears in exactly one listing in this category, and this is it. Every other Wi-Fi claim here is either Wi-Fi 6, long-range Wi-Fi, or nothing at all.

    Amazon Fire TV Stick 4K Max (newest model)

    • The apps

    The listing states AI-powered Fire TV Search, Wi-Fi 6E support, and free and live TV without cable or satellite. Wi-Fi 6E is the one figure in this category that no other listing states.

    What the listing states

    • Wi-Fi 6E support is stated, and no other listing in this category states it
    • A Fire TV platform is stated, so the apps job is covered by the listing
    • AI-powered Fire TV Search is stated by name rather than described loosely
    • Free and live TV without cable or satellite is stated in the listing text

    What it does not

    • The listing names no remote, so the input job is left to whatever is already on the table
    • No assistant is named, unlike three of the five sticks in this group
    • A stated Wi-Fi generation says nothing about the network already in the room

    SuitsA buyer who cares which Wi-Fi generation a listing states, and who has read what their own network actually is.

    View listing
  • Amazon Fire TV Stick HD (newest model)
    Stated as powered by the TV

    Powered by the TV appears in exactly one listing in this category. Nothing else here says anything at all about where the device gets its power.

    Amazon Fire TV Stick HD (newest model)

    • The apps
    • The input

    The listing states free and live TV, an Alexa Voice Remote, that it is powered by the TV, and Alexa+. It is one of two Fire TV Stick HD listings in this catalog, and they carry different ASINs, so neither is treated as the only one of its kind.

    • This is one of two Fire TV Stick HD listings in this catalog. The other carries a different ASIN and different listing text, and neither is described here as the only Fire TV Stick HD.

    What the listing states

    • An Alexa Voice Remote is stated in the box, which most listings in this group do not state
    • Being powered by the TV is stated, and no other listing in this category states anything about power
    • A Fire TV platform is stated, so the apps job is covered
    • Free and live TV is stated alongside the remote

    What it does not

    • The remote it states is the sixth remote this catalog counts in the streaming category alone
    • No resolution above HD is stated, unlike three of its neighbors in this group
    • A second listing in this catalog carries the same product name and a different ASIN, so the name alone will not identify it

    SuitsA screen that needs a Fire TV platform and a remote in the same box, at the HD naming rather than the 4K naming.

    View listing
  • Amazon Fire TV Stick HD
    Second HD stick, its own ASIN

    Two listings in this catalog are named Fire TV Stick HD and they carry different ASINs. This badge records that fact instead of pretending one of them is unique.

    Amazon Fire TV Stick HD

    • The apps
    • The input

    The listing states free and live TV, an Alexa Voice Remote, smart home controls and HD streaming. It shares its product name with another listing in this catalog and carries its own ASIN, which is exactly why the name is not enough to identify it.

    • This is one of two Fire TV Stick HD listings in this catalog. The other carries a different ASIN and different listing text, and neither is described here as the only Fire TV Stick HD.

    What the listing states

    • An Alexa Voice Remote is stated in the box
    • Smart home controls are stated, which the other Fire TV Stick HD listing does not state
    • A Fire TV platform is stated, so the set it plugs into gains a second one
    • HD streaming is stated plainly rather than implied by the model name

    What it does not

    • It shares a product name with a different ASIN in this catalog, so the two are easy to confuse
    • No Wi-Fi generation, storage figure or audio format is stated
    • The stated remote adds to a category that already states six remotes in its boxes

    SuitsSomebody comparing the two Fire TV Stick HD listings side by side, who wants the one that states smart home controls.

    View listing

Roku players

Three listings

Every listing in this group states a Roku platform. One of the three is marked Renewed by the seller, and one names itself an HD product while describing itself as a 4K product in the same listing.

Roku players: three listings compared on six points that differ

Identical on all three, so not shown as a columnPlatform stated: Roku.

Roku players, compared on the points where the listings differ
ListingResolution statedHDR statedWi-Fi statedRemote statedAudio formats statedSeller condition
Roku Streaming Stick HDHD in the product name, 4K in the descriptionNot statedLong-range Wi-FiRoku Voice RemoteNot statedNot stated
Roku UltraNot statedHDR10+ and Dolby VisionWi-Fi 6Rechargeable Voice Remote Pro with backlit buttonsDolby AtmosNot stated
Roku Streaming Stick 4K, RenewedRenewed4KHDR and Dolby VisionLong-range Wi-FiVoice remoteNot statedRenewed

Six of the recorded points differ across this group. Where a listing says nothing, the cell reads not stated, which is not the same as absent.

  • Roku Streaming Stick HD with Voice Remote
    The listing contradicts itself

    The product name says Streaming Stick HD. The description in the same listing says compact 4K streaming device. Both are quoted on this page and neither is treated as settled.

    Roku Streaming Stick HD with Voice Remote

    • The apps
    • The input

    The listing names this product Streaming Stick HD and, in the same description, calls it a compact 4K streaming device. Those two statements do not agree with each other. This site quotes both and says so, rather than picking whichever is more convenient.

    • Contradiction in the listing: the product is named Streaming Stick HD, and the description in the same listing calls it a compact 4K streaming device. This site does not resolve that. Ask the seller before assuming either figure.

    What the listing states

    • A Roku platform is stated, so the apps job is covered by the listing
    • A Roku Voice Remote is stated in the box
    • Long-range Wi-Fi is stated
    • Free and live TV is stated on the Roku side of the catalog too

    What it does not

    • The listing contradicts itself on resolution: HD in the product name, 4K in the description
    • Because of that contradiction, nothing on this site treats its resolution as settled
    • Long-range Wi-Fi is stated by a second listing in this group as well, so it distinguishes nothing here

    SuitsSomebody who wants the Roku platform and is prepared to ask the seller which of the two resolution statements is the correct one.

    View listing
  • Roku Ultra, Ultimate Streaming Player
    Only Dolby Atmos stated here

    Dolby Atmos appears in exactly one listing in this category. Every other player and display here states no audio format at all.

    Roku Ultra, Ultimate Streaming Player

    • The apps
    • The input

    The listing states HDR10+, Dolby Vision, Dolby Atmos, Bluetooth, Wi-Fi 6 and a rechargeable Voice Remote Pro with backlit buttons. It is the only listing in this category that names an audio format, which makes it the one player here that touches the sound job in its own text.

    What the listing states

    • Dolby Atmos is stated, and no other listing in this category states an audio format
    • A rechargeable Voice Remote Pro with backlit buttons is stated in the box
    • HDR10+ and Dolby Vision are both stated
    • Wi-Fi 6 and Bluetooth are both stated in one listing

    What it does not

    • A stated audio format is a statement about what the device passes along, not about speakers it contains
    • No resolution figure is stated in the listing text quoted here
    • The stated remote is a seventh remote in a category that already states six

    SuitsA room where the format names on the box matter to whoever is choosing, and where a rechargeable remote is worth the extra thing to charge.

    View listing
  • Roku Streaming Stick 4K (Renewed)
    Renewed, not new

    Renewed appears as a stated seller condition on exactly one listing in this catalog. It is a different thing to buy, so it is a badge rather than a footnote.

    Renewed. This listing is marked Renewed by the seller and is not a new device.

    Roku Streaming Stick 4K (Renewed)

    • The apps
    • The input

    Renewed. The listing states HDR, Dolby Vision, a voice remote, long-range Wi-Fi and free and live TV, and it is marked Renewed by the seller. That word changes what is being bought, so it is printed on the card, in the tools, and in every mention of this listing on the site.

    • Renewed. This listing is marked Renewed by the seller. A Renewed device is not a new device, and what Renewed covers is set by the seller program, not by this site.

    What the listing states

    • A Roku platform is stated, the same one two other listings in this group state
    • HDR and Dolby Vision are both stated
    • A voice remote is stated in the box
    • The Renewed condition is stated by the seller rather than left to be discovered

    What it does not

    • Renewed is not a new device, and this catalog never presents it as one
    • The listing is the only Renewed entry in this catalog, so there is nothing here to compare its condition against
    • Long-range Wi-Fi is stated by another listing in this group as well

    SuitsSomebody who has read the seller Renewed terms and has decided that is what they are buying.

    View listing

Google TV

One listing

One listing states a Google TV platform, so there is nothing in this catalog to compare it against and no comparison table is drawn for it.

A single listing sits in this group, so no comparison table is drawn. There is nothing here to compare it against, and putting it in a table on its own would suggest otherwise.

  • Google TV Streamer 4K, Hazel
    Only storage figure stated here

    32 GB is the single storage figure stated anywhere in this category. No other listing here states how much storage it has.

    Google TV Streamer 4K, Hazel

    • The apps
    • The input

    The listing states a voice search remote, HDR, smart home control and 32 GB of storage. It is the only Google TV listing in this catalog, so it has nothing here to be compared against and no comparison table is drawn for it.

    What the listing states

    • 32 GB of storage is stated, and no other listing in this category states a storage figure
    • A Google TV platform is stated, which no television in this catalog states
    • A voice search remote is stated in the box
    • HDR and smart home control are both stated

    What it does not

    • It is the only Google TV listing here, so there is no comparison table for it on the category page
    • A platform no television here states also means no television here can be doubling it
    • The stated remote is another remote in a room that probably has several

    SuitsA household already using Google TV elsewhere, or one deliberately choosing a platform that none of the televisions in this catalog states.

    View listing

Smart displays

Three listings

These are smart displays, not players for a television. Two of the three state no television platform at all. Only the third states a television platform built into the display.

Smart displays: three listings compared on three points that differ

Identical on all three, so not shown as a columnAssistant stated: Alexa+.

Smart displays, compared on the points where the listings differ
ListingPlatform statedResolution statedAudio formats stated
Echo Show 5Not statedNot statedTwice the bass and clearer sound
Echo Show 11Not statedFull HD, 11 inch displaySpatial audio
Echo Show 15Fire TV, built into the displayFull HD, 15.6 inch displayNot stated

Three of the recorded points differ across this group. Where a listing says nothing, the cell reads not stated, which is not the same as absent.

  • Amazon Echo Show 5 (newest model), Charcoal
    Twice the bass stated

    The phrase twice the bass appears in this listing and nowhere else in the catalog. It is an audio claim on a device that states no television platform, which is the whole point of the group it sits in.

    Amazon Echo Show 5 (newest model), Charcoal

    The listing states a smart display designed for Alexa+, twice the bass and clearer sound. It states no television platform of any kind. It is filed in this category because that is where a retail catalog puts it, and it does not do the job the rest of this category is sold for.

    • This is a smart display, not a player for a television. The listing states no television platform.

    What the listing states

    • The listing is clear about what it is: a smart display, not a player for a television
    • Twice the bass is stated, and no other listing in this category states that
    • Alexa+ is stated as what the display is designed for
    • Nothing in the listing overstates a television role it does not claim

    What it does not

    • It states no television platform, so it does not do the apps job on a television at all
    • It states no remote, so it adds nothing to the input job either
    • Filing it in a streaming category invites exactly the confusion this site exists to reduce

    SuitsA kitchen counter or a bedside table. Not a television that needs an app platform.

    View listing
  • Amazon Echo Show 11 (newest model), Graphite
    Spatial audio stated

    Spatial audio appears in this listing and in no other listing in the catalog. It is stated on a display that states no television platform.

    Amazon Echo Show 11 (newest model), Graphite

    The listing states a full-HD eleven inch display with spatial audio, designed for Alexa+. Like the smaller display beside it, it states no television platform, so it does not do the job the rest of this category is sold for.

    • This is a smart display, not a player for a television. The listing states no television platform.

    What the listing states

    • A screen size and a resolution are both stated, which two other listings in this group do not both state
    • Spatial audio is stated, and no other listing in this category states it
    • The listing names Alexa+ as the reason the display exists
    • The listing makes no television platform claim it cannot support

    What it does not

    • It states no television platform, so it does not add apps to a television
    • It states no remote, so it adds nothing to the input job
    • Sitting in a streaming category makes it look like a television device, which it does not claim to be

    SuitsA room that wants a display with Alexa+ on it. Not a television that needs an app platform.

    View listing
  • Amazon Echo Show 15 (newest model)
    Only display stating a TV platform

    Three smart displays are filed in this category. This is the only one whose listing states a television platform built into the display; the other two state none.

    Amazon Echo Show 15 (newest model)

    • The apps

    The listing states a full HD 15.6 inch kitchen hub with built-in Fire TV, designed for Alexa+. Of the three smart displays in this catalog, it is the only one that states a television platform inside it, which means it is the only one that touches the apps job at all.

    • This is a smart display with a television platform stated inside it. It is a second screen, not an addition to the television in the living room.

    What the listing states

    • Built-in Fire TV is stated, and no other display in this catalog states a television platform
    • A screen size and a resolution are both stated
    • Alexa+ is named alongside the television platform
    • One wall bracket in this catalog names this display by name, which is a rare cross-category link

    What it does not

    • It is a display in its own right, so a Fire TV platform on it is not a Fire TV platform on the television
    • It states no remote, so nothing here reaches the television across the room
    • It states no audio format, unlike both smaller displays in this group

    SuitsA kitchen that wants a screen with a platform on it, understood as a second screen rather than an addition to the first one.

    View listing

Questions about streaming players & displays

Does a streaming player replace the platform already in a smart television?

It does not remove it. Both platforms stay in the room, and both listings describe the same job. Which one gets used is a matter of which input the television is on.

Are the two Fire TV Stick HD listings the same product?

They carry different ASINs and different listing text, so this catalog treats them as two listings. Neither is described here as the only one of its kind, because they share most of what they state.

Why are smart displays in a streaming category?

Because that is where a retail catalog files them. This site groups them apart and prints what each one states about a television platform, which for two of the three is nothing.

GearOverlapsGlossary